Marketing & Sales
An enterprise purchases HubSpot CRM.
- Problem
- Finding more customers and tracking lead conversion
- Product
- HubSpot CRM
- People
- Marketing and sales teams
- Protocol
- Inbound marketing optimization and automated lead management workflows
Product, Problem, People and Protocol. Four elements that help a business orient and execute its digital transformation, and create lasting value in the digital era.
The core question
Which specific Product empowers People to overcome a critical Problem through a seamless Protocol?
About 4P
The 4P model is a comprehensive management framework that helps businesses orient and execute the transformation process effectively. It focuses on four core elements: People, Problem, Product and Protocol.
Optimizing these four elements and connecting them in sync helps organizations not only modernize their operational processes but also create sustainable new value in the digital era.
The framework
Start with why: the Problem comes first, then the Product, the People and the Protocol. Leave one out and the change does not hold.
The critical challenge that makes the change worth doing.
What the enterprise builds, buys or deploys to create value.
Everyone who uses the product or lives with the problem.
How people interact: with each other, with the product and with the problem.
A closer look at Product
An enterprise can build a product in house or buy it. Buying no longer means owning: more and more products are rented, subscribed to or paid for per use, so they reach the enterprise as a service.
The enterprise develops the product itself and owns it.
The enterprise pays once and keeps the product for good.
The enterprise pays to use the product for as long as it needs it.
Product as a Service replaces the one-time sale with new ways to access or use a product. KPMG names four models:
Use for a set period.
Event apparel, short-term car rental
Longer-term use without ownership.
IT equipment, solar panels, car leases
A recurring flat rate for access.
Bike share, gym membership, streaming
Pay for each use; the product is shared.
Ride-hailing, scooters, laundromats
Source: KPMG, “Circular Business Model Innovation: Product-as-a-Service”
In 4P, it is still the Product. Owned, subscribed or paid per use, the Product answers What. That is why HubSpot CRM, Google Workspace and a ride-hailing app all appear as the Product in the examples below.
Transformation
Transformation does not have to start big. A change to any one of the four Ps moves the other three.
Examples
From farms to banks to AI coding assistants, every example answers the same four questions.
An enterprise purchases HubSpot CRM.
A retail chain deploys a loyalty application.
A manufacturing plant applies an IoT sensor system to monitor equipment.
A hospital implements a telehealth portal.
An agricultural farm applies a smart automated irrigation system.
A university deploys a learning management system.
A logistics company uses a routing and waypoint optimization platform.
A hotel brand launches a contactless check-in app.
A power grid management unit applies an advanced metering infrastructure system.
A real estate platform integrates 3D virtual tour technology.
A movie theater chain deploys an automated QR code ticketing system.
A bank implements an electronic know-your-customer solution.
A high-quality bus system deploys real-time electronic schedule boards.
A construction contractor applies building information modeling.
A ride-hailing app helps passengers and drivers.
An enterprise deploys a generative AI assistant.
An enterprise deploys an automated invoice processing system.
An enterprise implements a knowledge management and CRM sales pipeline platform.
An enterprise adopts an open corporate chat platform.
A retail brand launches an integrated social commerce feature.
A retail brand launches an online storefront platform.
An enterprise migrates to Google Workspace.
An enterprise deploys an AI-powered conversational support platform.
A retail organization implements an AI demand forecasting system.
A software company adopts an AI developer assistant.
Coca-Cola launches a new beverage line.
An enterprise implements an automated regulatory compliance platform.